Re: Was there ever a clinic on Delano-based paint and weathering?

Robert kirkham

That’s a pretty smart test for slides.  I like it.  


On Nov 13, 2020, at 4:15 PM, Andy Carlson <midcentury@...> wrote:

Since my becoming a RR slide collector I have a rule of thumb as a critic of color images. I imagine that what view I am looking at is from the view looking outside from the inside of an open window. If I feel that I can be fooled into believing I am viewing a real outside image, I consider the slide to be good. Almost all slides which pass this test are Kodachromes taken in "Kodachrome" lighting (Nice full sun).

The image posted on a current cover of one of Ted Cullota's offerings is a Delano photo of New Mexico in 1942. That image views well in my believability function. I would trust any colors from that to be superior and much more trusted than any image photo-minipulated.

-Andy Carlson, Ojai CA

On Friday, November 13, 2020, 11:17:35 AM PST, Dave Nelson <lake_muskoka@...> wrote:

I have similar concerns.  I’ve pulled a fair number of Delano’s photos into a top end photo editor and “adjusted” them.  They look better.  But what I wonder is this: Is today’s “better” simply artificially saturated?  Is today’s “better” bright, clear light that maybe wasn’t present when the photo was taken?  Delano was shooting in December.  I know Chicago Decembers and there are more than a fair share of pretty gloomy days.


All of which leaves me wondering the exact same question raised by Dave Evans, below – that maybe these old images ARE exactly what freight cars looked like in December, 1943, in and around Chicago.  I just don’t know but I do hesitate to label them off in any way.


Dave Nelson


From: [] On Behalf Of devansprr
Sent: Friday, November 13, 2020 10:02 AM
Subject: Re: [RealSTMFC] Was there ever a clinic on Delano-based paint and weathering?


Re: Delano film color

I thought Delano's WWII color film was Kodachrome? Arguably the most accurate and stable color film of that era?

What better reference do we have?
Dave Evans

Join to automatically receive all group messages.