Corey,

That second truck looks more like it.  from the looks of it, an Andrews truck wouldn't be hard to replicate.  I, for one, find the detail adequate.

Here's a photo from March, 1943 showing the Andrews version in good detail.  For anyone interested, this is from the Library of Congress FSA/OWI collection.  It was taken by Jack Delano on a cross country trip where he rode Santa Fe freight trains and made photos of railroad subjects as he went.

-Jeff Ford
Sanger, TX