Re: RC PFE R-30-12-9
Garth G. Groff <ggg9y@...>
Mike,toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Let me say by way of clarification, there is no physical or photographic evidence of the R-30-12 underframes under any WP-owned PFE cars, as discussed in Tony's PFE book. One might have expected the first 200 cars to have had the -12 Bettendorf underframes, but the builder's photo in his book clearly shows the -13 built-up underframe bolster ends. No numbers can be attached to the supposed R-30-12 underframes, and I am of the opinion that they were never actually built this way.
Based on suggestions by Richard Hendrickson in one of his articles in DING when these RC models were new, I built modified several of these cars with the Tichy parts. Not hard at all. Both my WP cars have them, and I also did some regular PFE cars as R-30-13-9s (R-30-9s by my 1950s period).
R-40-6s had both Bettendorf and "built-up" underframes (they were actually rebuilds of cars from several classes). By a stroke of luck, the last one with a "built-up" underframe was scrapped in 1956, two years before my time period. All my R-40-6 cars use the stock RC Bettendorf underframes, and have correct numbers from the remaining cars circa 1958.
Garth G. Groff
Mike Brock wrote:
Garth Groff writes: