Tim writes:

**** Thanks Steve. You're right but I have ignored the treatment of the flat-bottom top major rib because EVERYONE in the hobby biz has ignored it (in HO scale) with one Accurail exception (I think; from memory). ****

Your memory is pretty good - Accurail does make a rthin/3/3 end for some of it's reefer kits. Bill Welch posted a teaser shot a year or so ago ahead of one of his clinics. The pic did include a rthin/3/4 end. I queried him off list and he turned me on to the Accurail ends. I've got four sets here that I'm attempting to convert into a viable master suitable for casting enough in resin to cover my needs (Four dozen or so for GN, SP&S, and perhaps other cars). Unfortunately, my skills at removing ladders, brake housings, and tack boards from curve services is lacking . . . . . . ☹

**** There are dozens and dozens of examples where that feature is missing from our models. :-( ****

Yep Almost 20K cars with the IDN-2 end. I'm doing some Excel work to see if I can't do a nice job of summarizing Ed's data by various IDN-2 configurations - maybe a nice summary might temp someone to consider marketing additional end options.

Best regards,

Steve

Steve Haas
Snoqualmie, WA

Hi John and Group

Yes, I frequently get taken to the group home page instead of the attachment I had clicked on in an e-mail.  This is primarily .jpg's in my case but I have also come across .pdf's that won't load.  I have found that I can sometimes view the offending attachment by going into the list of messages on the groups.io site and clicking on the link there, but it is not always available.

Regards
Paul Woods

These are the AMC version of the 1920s ARA steel-sheathed box, with the "innie" version of the early Dreadnaught end.

This drawing shows the taller Dreadnaught end on N&W class BT, but the general profile is the same:
https://www.nwhs.org/archivesdb/detail.php?ID=14919

David Thompson

I'm inclined to think this is someone's outside metal roof, and not any sort of all-steel roof.

David Thompson

On Fri, Mar 13, 2020 at 12:23 PM, Gene Deimling wrote:

It appears to be a Viking roof similar to those used on SP boxcars

Yeah, it does, but I don't think the Viking name was in use in 1916, being a trade name Chicago-Cleveland transitioned to some time around WWII.

Dennis Storzek

Elliot,

SPECIAL NOTICE – Toronto Railway Prototype Modellers Meet postponement

 

Current public health concerns due to the spreading of Covid -9 have compelled us to postpone the Toronto Railway Prototype Modellers Meet scheduled to be held on Sat. Mar. 21 at Humber College to a later date at the College. Many of us are older and have a higher risk of contracting the virus. We cannot ensure that proper social distance can be maintained at Humber. We hope that anybody who has paid for travel tickets will be able to get full reimbursement given this situation. Safety for all is our primary concern.

Below are the websites of the three government public health websites where you can get the latest information about Covid 19.

 

https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/diseases/coronavirus-disease-covid-19.html

 

https://www.publichealthontario.ca/en/diseases-and-conditions/infectious-diseases/respiratory-diseases/novel-coronavirus

 

https://www.toronto.ca/community-people/health-wellness-care/diseases-medications-vaccines/coronavirus/

 

We regret having to take this measure and hope that you will continue to support our Meet in the future when we look forward to again having a great day of modelling fun and cameraderie! We will continue to work with Humber College and will contact you when we are able to reschedule the meet.

 

Please pass this information onto anybody you know who usually comes to the Meet or has expressed interest in attending.

 

Our sincerest best wishes to all that you and yours may remain healthy through this challenging time.

 

James Whatley Richard McQuade Brian Gauer

Organizers of the Toronto Railway Prototype Modellers Meet

It appears to be a Viking roof similar to those used on SP boxcars

Gene Deimling 

The Valley Forge RPM has been cancelled due to Corona virus.

-- John

--

I agree that it's a radial roof, but it doesn't seem to match the images of the Hutchins "camber" roof in the 1916 CBC.  I don't know who made that roof.
--
Dave Parker
Swall Meadows, CA

Hutchins Dry Lading Roof?

A photo taken in 1916:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/ssave/39075615572/in/album-72157689846832316/

Is this an example of a Hutchins Dry Lading roof?

Thanks.

Bob Chaparro

Hemet, CA

Great model! What size chain and brass strip do you need for the brake cylinder pulley assembly? My sunshine kit of the soo sawtooth did not include either. 

Thanks,
Elliot 

A "recommend" from me for the Toronto RPM.  It's relatively small but has been growing.  Several historical societies are attending this year.

This is the geographically closest one to me (international border notwithstanding).  I have been watching to ensure it's still on given the current COVID-19 situation but so far that appears to be the case.

https://torontoprototypemodellers.wordpress.com/

Cheers,
George Irwin

The presentation PDF is on Ted blog.

Link to Kitbash PDF

It is about halfway down with photos of cars 10925 and 10857.

Scott McDonald 

I must have mistranscribed the GN group.

I mentioned the flat bottom of the top rib in a second post.

Thanks!

Randy
—
Randy Hammill
Prototype Junction
http://prototypejunction.com

Modeling the New Haven Railroad 1946-1954
http://newbritainstation.com