Date   

Re: Seeking A Tool

Jim Betz
 

Hi,
  For the small holes we are wanting to counter sink ... wouldn't it be nice if (WIBNI)
we had a tool that was based on an abrasive technology rather than cutting.  I'm
thinking that a diamond coated counter sink - without any cutter - would do the
jobs that I need very well ... and not run the risk of catching and chipping out
the edge of the hole ... and not wear out (because it is diamond).
                                                                                                       - Jim in the PNW


Re: Seeking A Tool

mark_landgraf
 

You might try BenchmarkAbrasives.com

They offer two 90 degree Countersink Premium Tungsten Carbide Burrs.  Check out their SK-3 and SK-5. 

I regularly use the 5 on my drill press for a variety of sizes of hole sizes. With the high quantity of cutting teeth it acts like a file. No vibrations. 

Hope this helps
Mark Landgraf


On Sun, Oct 30, 2022 at 4:05 PM, spsalso via groups.io
<Edwardsutorik@...> wrote:
Just yesterday I used a cutting tool that is new to me:  a device that cuts a countersink, and is designed to fit on a drill bit.

It did a superb job.  In this case, I was countersinking 10-32 oval head screws in 1/8" nickel silver, using a drill press.  I had already drilled a clearance hole using a #9 bit.

It's made by Vernon Devices.

Here's a link to their catalog (see page 13):

http://www.vernondevices.com/pdfs/2010VernonDevicesCatalog.pdf

They make these devices that will fit down to a #52 bit, so you can do 0-80 countersinking.

What I liked about these is there was NO chatter, and the countersink was perfectly centered on the hole.  

They are not inexpensive.  But, for this job, I needed perfection; and it delivered.  I expect, over time, I will get other sizes.  One nice thing is the bit is easily sharpened.


Ed

Edward Sutorik


Re: Tank Car Belly Shots (and Wabash panel side hoppers)

Dave Nelson
 

GATX 30636 and GATX 5259

 

Dave Nelson _._,_._,_


Re: Bifurcated rib boxcar end (was UP Automobile Boxcar 151056 (1940))

 

Cannon & Co. makes a bifurcated end
Rich Christie


Re: Seeking A Tool

spsalso
 

Just yesterday I used a cutting tool that is new to me:  a device that cuts a countersink, and is designed to fit on a drill bit.

It did a superb job.  In this case, I was countersinking 10-32 oval head screws in 1/8" nickel silver, using a drill press.  I had already drilled a clearance hole using a #9 bit.

It's made by Vernon Devices.

Here's a link to their catalog (see page 13):

http://www.vernondevices.com/pdfs/2010VernonDevicesCatalog.pdf

They make these devices that will fit down to a #52 bit, so you can do 0-80 countersinking.

What I liked about these is there was NO chatter, and the countersink was perfectly centered on the hole.  

They are not inexpensive.  But, for this job, I needed perfection; and it delivered.  I expect, over time, I will get other sizes.  One nice thing is the bit is easily sharpened.


Ed

Edward Sutorik


Bifurcated rib boxcar end (was UP Automobile Boxcar 151056 (1940))

Richard Townsend
 

Does/did anyone make HO boxcar ends with the bifurcated ribs?

Richard Townsend
Lincoln City, OR


Re: UP Automobile Boxcar 151056 (1940)

Dave Nelson
 

Anyone having doubts about the forces in railroading only need to look at those rails -- bent like they were just pipe cleaners.

Dave Nelson

-----Original Message-----
From: main@RealSTMFC.groups.io <main@RealSTMFC.groups.io> On Behalf Of David via groups.io
Sent: Friday, October 28, 2022 3:48 PM
To: RealSTMFC@groups.io
Subject: [RealSTMFC] UP Automobile Boxcar 151056 (1940)

https://aadl.org/sites/default/files/photos/N186_0021_011.jpg
This GTW steel-side rebuild has a short intermediate panel in the end to accomodate a height extension, not an uncommon practice. I haven't seen one of those with a single bifurcated rib, though.

David Thompson


Re: Seeking A Tool

Lester Breuer
 

Bill I have attached a photo showing the various ones I use when needed.  All are turned by hand to produce a countersunk hole
and if sharp an easy task.


Lester Breuer
Plymouth, MN


Re: Allen McClelland has had a stroke

Doug Paasch
 

Yes, sad news.  He was very inspiring.  Here is a memorial at trains.com

 

https://www.trains.com/mrr/news-reviews/news/in-memoriam-allen-mcclelland/

 

    Doug Paasch

 

From: main@RealSTMFC.groups.io <main@RealSTMFC.groups.io> On Behalf Of Gerry Fitzgerald
Sent: Saturday, October 29, 2022 11:50 AM
To: main@realstmfc.groups.io
Subject: Re: [RealSTMFC] Allen McClelland has had a stroke

 

This is very sad news indeed. Allen McClelland’s published work on the V&O captivated me a young person in the hobby and has kept me in model railroading ever since.

 

Unfortunately Allen won't see the publication of Tony's new book on his contributions to the hobby. While I never got to see either V&O layout in person, I was lucky enough to have had lunch with Tony and Allen at an NMRA regional meet in West Virginia during my first or second year of graduate school. Tony invited me to sit down with them to eat as I was close at hand and he already knew me and there was a small crowd following them around. As I recall Tony might have done most of the talking but Allen seemed like a nice person and he cordially answered all my V&O questions. I am not sure what I asked him but he was very accommodating. Had I known I was going to meet him I would have brought along a copy of the V&O Story.  

 

I wrote a think piece on the historical impact of the V&O for the Fall 2008 Layout Design SIG Journal (LDJ 39) and I am very glad that I did since the V&O will always be the biggest reason I got more interested in the hobby. I have a number of WWII era V&O freight cars in my fleet for interchange and operational use.

 

Allen will be missed by many as his various contributions made our hobby much more realistic, fun, and interesting. My condolences to Mr. McClelland’s family.


Re: Seeking A Tool

Dennis Storzek
 

On Fri, Oct 28, 2022 at 08:09 PM, Nelson Moyer wrote:
I looked for a countersink for 2-56 flat head machine screws, but didn’t find one with a 45° angle.
Point of information, 2-56 flat head screws have an included angle of 82*, or 41* from centerline. Metric screws use a 90* countersink, but that will only give a single line of contact with the steeper head.

I happen to like single flute countersinks as they are less likely to chatter. But I see a problem... if you are using a Dremel drill press that means you are limited to a 1/8" shank, right? Countersinks this small have the shank the same diameter as the cutter diameter, and you need 3/16" for that #2 flat head (.162" to be exact) and any 3/16" countersink I've found has a 3/16" diameter shank. Sorry.

Dennis Storzek


Re: Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

Guy Wilber
 


Bob Chaparro wrote:

“I’ve noticed photos of freight cars sometimes show small advertising posters, presumably attached by the shipper.
The photos appear to be pre-World War One.
Were such posters banned or outlawed at some point? And when?”

Here’s a brief overview of the prohibition of advertising on freight cars. All such rules were promulgated by the various railroad associations. The Interstate Commerce Commission had no involvement regarding these rules other than the use of placards which they mandated. If you need more details let me know.

The American Railway Association included Rule 14 within its first Code of Car Service Rules adopted October 24, 1900.

Rule 14: The placing of advertisements or placards of any kind by shippers upon freight cars is prohibited.

The rule was, “recommendatory and not binding upon any member” as per the ARA’s Articles of Organization. As the abuses continued The ARA referred the subject to the 1907 annual meeting of The Master Car Builders’ Association with recommendations that car inspectors be instructed to remove advertisements at all inspection points and charge the cost of the work to the delivering line.

The MCBA’s Arbitration Committee original response was, “Your committee has carefully considered the matter, and is of the opinion that, as it is not a matter which affects the interchange of cars, maintenance of standards or settlement of cars, it is a subject which to rule upon would be entirely outside the providence of this association.”

The following day the secretary of the MCBA addressed the members of the Arbitration Committee and stated, “I wish to say that yesterday afternoon at 4:30 there was a meeting of the Arbitration Committee at which there were representatives of some of the prominent railroads of the United States. They conferred with the Arbitration Committee, and as a result of that conference the Arbitration Committee modified some of its suggestions and those I would like to read it this time:

(1) That the recommendation on page 2 of the printed report of the committee relating to the placing of advertisements on cars be reconsidered.

(2) That rule 40 be changed to read: Damage of any kind to the body of the car due to unfair usage, derailment or accident; also temporary advertisements tacked, glued, pasted or varnished on cars. Delivering company responsible.

Additionally, the following was added to Interchange Rule 106 covering the amounts chargeable to delivering lines. “Removing temporary advertisements tacked on cars, per car, fifty (50) cents. Removing temporary advertisements glued pasted or varnished on cars, per car, one dollar ($1.00)”

The changes to rules 40 and 106 were adopted by the Master Car Builders’ Association on September 1, 1907.

After several changes and expansion of both —Interchange Rule 40 became Rule 36 and Car Service Rule 14 became 12. Both remained throughout the scope of this list so numbered.

Beginning in 1920 with the reorganization of The American Railway Association the Transportation Division reported on the adherence to Car Service Rule 12 and Interchange Rule 36 which were worded exactly the same. Few abuses of the rule were reported during subsequent years and by 1925 the practice of applying advertisements was non existent.

Guy Wilber
Reno, Nevada


Re: Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

Eric Hiser
 

By 1914 they were banned under the Code of Car Service Rules.

 

AT&SF Eric

 

From: main@RealSTMFC.groups.io <main@RealSTMFC.groups.io> On Behalf Of Eric Hansmann
Sent: Saturday, October 29, 2022 10:47 AM
To: main@RealSTMFC.groups.io; Bob Chaparro via groups.io <chiefbobbb@...>
Subject: Re: [RealSTMFC] Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

 

Bob,

 

I do not have a date or a regulation for the end of use, but they fade away by the mid-Teens. Your examples illustrate smaller signs on cars that seem to be en-route.

 

There are many publicity photos taken in later years showing banners on freight cars. I think those banners were removed before the cars were pulled from sidings to move toward destinations.

 

 

Eric Hansmann
Murfreesboro, TN

 

On 10/29/2022 11:58 AM CDT Bob Chaparro via groups.io <chiefbobbb@...> wrote:

 

 

Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

I’ve noticed photos of freight cars sometimes show small advertising posters, presumably attached by the shipper.

The photos appear to be pre-World War One.

Were such posters banned or outlawed at some point? And when?

Thanks.

Bob Chaparro

Hemet, CA

 

 

 


Re: Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

Dave Wetterstroem
 

I was searching for something else and came across this. This was from a candle company that used beeswax.  


Minneapolis & St. Louis Gondola 30357

Lester Breuer
 

I built and upgraded Northwoods Models, Soo Parts Minneapolis & St. Louis (M&STL)  general service gondola one piece body resin 3D printed kit 22080 I numbered 30357.  One unique feature is the inset on the bottom of the side sheets.  Upgrade includes AB brakes and making sill steps from brass.  If you are interested in the build of resin 3D  printed M&STL gondola, photos and write up of the build process including testing of Badger 3D Prime, a two part Translucent Surface Smoother (striation filler) for 3D printed materials, painting, lettering from Circus City Decals and weathering are now available on my blog I have to share photos and writeup of modeling projects on my Minneapolis & Northland Railroad Company.  If you would like to take a look please do at the following link:

 

http://mnrailroadcab100.blogspot.com/

 

Lester Breuer

 


Re: Great Northern safety film - lots of period freight cars

Kenneth Montero
 

Also the use of a model railroad to demonstrate the consequences of failing to go at a slower speed when the approach signal is made.

Ken Montero

On 10/29/2022 2:46 PM Charlie Duckworth via groups.io <worth51@...> wrote:


Great Northern safety film.   Besides GN equipment there’s Southern SU boxcar, NOT&M SS boxcar and more.  

https://youtu.be/BqpayZ2JqlU
--
Charlie Duckworth 
Omaha, Ne.


Re: Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

Tim O'Connor
 


I suspect the railroads (or even other customers) got tired of this practice and made it cease and
desist since the labels don't appear to be easy to remove.


On 10/29/2022 12:58 PM, Bob Chaparro via groups.io wrote:

Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

I’ve noticed photos of freight cars sometimes show small advertising posters, presumably attached by the shipper.

The photos appear to be pre-World War One.

Were such posters banned or outlawed at some point? And when?

Thanks.

Bob Chaparro



--
Tim O'Connor
Sterling, Massachusetts


Great Northern safety film - lots of period freight cars

Charlie Duckworth
 

Great Northern safety film.   Besides GN equipment there’s Southern SU boxcar, NOT&M SS boxcar and more.  

https://youtu.be/BqpayZ2JqlU
--
Charlie Duckworth 
Omaha, Ne.


Re: Allen McClelland has had a stroke

Gerry Fitzgerald
 

This is very sad news indeed. Allen McClelland’s published work on the V&O captivated me a young person in the hobby and has kept me in model railroading ever since.

 

Unfortunately Allen won't see the publication of Tony's new book on his contributions to the hobby. While I never got to see either V&O layout in person, I was lucky enough to have had lunch with Tony and Allen at an NMRA regional meet in West Virginia during my first or second year of graduate school. Tony invited me to sit down with them to eat as I was close at hand and he already knew me and there was a small crowd following them around. As I recall Tony might have done most of the talking but Allen seemed like a nice person and he cordially answered all my V&O questions. I am not sure what I asked him but he was very accommodating. Had I known I was going to meet him I would have brought along a copy of the V&O Story.  

 

I wrote a think piece on the historical impact of the V&O for the Fall 2008 Layout Design SIG Journal (LDJ 39) and I am very glad that I did since the V&O will always be the biggest reason I got more interested in the hobby. I have a number of WWII era V&O freight cars in my fleet for interchange and operational use.

 

Allen will be missed by many as his various contributions made our hobby much more realistic, fun, and interesting. My condolences to Mr. McClelland’s family.


Re: Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

Eric Hansmann
 

Bob,
 
I do not have a date or a regulation for the end of use, but they fade away by the mid-Teens. Your examples illustrate smaller signs on cars that seem to be en-route.
 
There are many publicity photos taken in later years showing banners on freight cars. I think those banners were removed before the cars were pulled from sidings to move toward destinations.
 
 
Eric Hansmann
Murfreesboro, TN
 

On 10/29/2022 11:58 AM CDT Bob Chaparro via groups.io <chiefbobbb@...> wrote:
 
 

Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

I’ve noticed photos of freight cars sometimes show small advertising posters, presumably attached by the shipper.

The photos appear to be pre-World War One.

Were such posters banned or outlawed at some point? And when?

Thanks.

Bob Chaparro

Hemet, CA



 

 


Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

Bob Chaparro
 

Advertising Posters On Freight Cars

I’ve noticed photos of freight cars sometimes show small advertising posters, presumably attached by the shipper.

The photos appear to be pre-World War One.

Were such posters banned or outlawed at some point? And when?

Thanks.

Bob Chaparro

Hemet, CA