"Xxtreme Modeling" presentation link


Bill Welch
 

For anyone interested here is the link to my "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation done at Cocoa Beach, Collinsville and Lisle in 2015: Xxtreme Modeling FINAL Web Version.pdf


It is copyrighted but it is okay to share with friends.


Bill


gtws00
 

Bill,
Thanks for posting this presentation link. You have a lot of good modeling tips in it.

George Toman


O Fenton Wells
 

Good stuff Bill.  You are the yardstick that the rest of our modeling efforts will be measured againxt.
Fenton Wells

On Mon, Oct 26, 2015 at 8:35 AM, fgexbill@... [STMFC] <STMFC@...> wrote:
 

For anyone interested here is the link to my "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation done at Cocoa Beach, Collinsville and Lisle in 2015: Xxtreme Modeling FINAL Web Version.pdf


It is copyrighted but it is okay to share with friends.


Bill




--
Fenton Wells
5 Newberry Lane
Pinehurst NC 28374
910-420-1144
srrfan1401@...


James E Kubanick
 

Bill,

Thank you for posting. Some really great guidelines for improving the finer details on our models. This should help many of us to become better prototype modelers.

Jim Kubanick
Morgantown WV



On Monday, October 26, 2015 8:35 AM, "fgexbill@... [STMFC]" wrote:


 
For anyone interested here is the link to my "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation done at Cocoa Beach, Collinsville and Lisle in 2015: Xxtreme Modeling FINAL Web Version.pdf

It is copyrighted but it is okay to share with friends.

Bill



Philip Lee
 

Good stuff. I kinda feel a bit intimidated now; a very few of my cars even have molded on grabs. Back to the car shop... :)
-Philip Lee



On Monday, October 26, 2015 5:19 PM, "James E Kubanick jekuban@... [STMFC]" wrote:


 
Bill,

Thank you for posting. Some really great guidelines for improving the finer details on our models. This should help many of us to become better prototype modelers.

Jim Kubanick
Morgantown WV



On Monday, October 26, 2015 8:35 AM, "fgexbill@... [STMFC]" wrote:


 
For anyone interested here is the link to my "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation done at Cocoa Beach, Collinsville and Lisle in 2015: Xxtreme Modeling FINAL Web Version.pdf

It is copyrighted but it is okay to share with friends.

Bill





Bill Welch
 

Dear Phillip:

I hope that feeling passes quickly as intimidation was far from my goal with this. Well not completely true, I do want to intimidate modelers to improve their sill steps. Just kidding, a little. Hah!

I am hoping I can inspire people to build. . . period. Don't be afraid of all those small parts and hey, you can even make some yourself. Do what makes you happy.

Recently I have confessed to anyone who will listen that I am intimidated by weathering, mainly because of my colorblindness, and once I did I started experimenting and from the feedback I have received I have been successful. We all have our growing edges.

Bill Welch


Philip Lee
 

Hi Bill,
I was joking. In all seriousness, that's pretty impressive. I'd definitely like for my cars to be that accurate; but, I'd also like to be able to do that sort of work on my own. I have built a few fairly basic resin kits, but I had never considered things like sill steps, tank car pipe/rod brackets, adding NBWs to brake wheels, etc. I think part of my hangup is my lack of knowledge about where details (especially underbody details) would have been placed, though I'm somewhat familiar with the general layouts of AB and K-brake systems (even these could vary too!). Hope to see some of your cars in person sometime.
-Phil Lee



On Wednesday, October 28, 2015 2:24 PM, "fgexbill@... [STMFC]" wrote:


 
Dear Phillip:

I hope that feeling passes quickly as intimidation was far from my goal with this. Well not completely true, I do want to intimidate modelers to improve their sill steps. Just kidding, a little. Hah!

I am hoping I can inspire people to build. . . period. Don't be afraid of all those small parts and hey, you can even make some yourself. Do what makes you happy.

Recently I have confessed to anyone who will listen that I am intimidated by weathering, mainly because of my colorblindness, and once I did I started experimenting and from the feedback I have received I have been successful. We all have our growing edges.

Bill Welch



Greg Martin
 

Bill,
 
What a great presentation. After seeing the presentation in CCB this past January the repeat was not as scary... 3^)
 
I love to see modeling like this and Schuyler as you well know is on the verge just you. 
 
I think regardless whatever we get out of this presentation what we should take away is that we should all return to modeling again. Challenge ourselves to take one of the examples here and apply them to out modeling. We should set a minimum set of standards for ourselves and as we get better move those standards ahead even if we start with something as simple as an ACCURAIL freight car. Hiding behind, "I have a layout to build and that takes all my time..." does really doesn't make sense when I see Clark do both. Turn off the computer and put your skills to the challenge.
 
I do want to say I am impressed.
 
Greg Martin
 
 
Eventually all things merge into one and a river runs through it.
Norman Maclean
 
In a message dated 10/26/2015 5:35:39 A.M. Pacific Daylight Time, STMFC@... writes:

 

For anyone interested here is the link to my "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation done at Cocoa Beach, Collinsville and Lisle in 2015: Xxtreme Modeling FINAL Web Version.pdf


It is copyrighted but it is okay to share with friends.


Bill


Clark Propst
 

I saw Bill’s clinic at Naperville. Afterwards a friend said. “Bet he doesn’t have a layout.” I think things need to be taken in context. I understand there are guys that just enjoy building models. Just because they choose to build train models doesn’t mean they ‘have’ to have a layout.
The higher you set the bar when building a layout the smaller it becomes, Bill Darnaby being an exception. Large layouts usually are built with a total different mindset where operations are foremost. At age 69 my new layout will be built realizing time is limited.
I haven’t been able to do any modeling since spring, but keep accumulating freight car kits and material for scratch building structures. Pretty soon I’m going to have to scratch that itch  ;  ))
Clark Propst
Mason City Iowa
 
I think regardless whatever we get out of this presentation what we should
take away is that we should all return to modeling again. Challenge
ourselves to take one of the examples here and apply them to out modeling. We
should set a minimum set of standards for ourselves and as we get better move
those standards ahead even if we start with something as simple as an
ACCURAIL freight car. Hiding behind, "I have a layout to build and that takes all
my time..." does really doesn't make sense when I see Clark do both. Turn
off the computer and put your skills to the challenge.


Greg Martin


tyesac@...
 

Right on that Greg & Clark.   One thing you could consider is that many model builders that don't have a home layout instead belong to a club.  That was my case while I lived in an apartment for several years.
 
The main thing though is put down that gadget and do somthing!
 
Tom Casey
 
I saw Bill’s clinic at Naperville. Afterwards a friend said. “Bet he doesn’t have a layout.” I think things need to be taken in context. I understand there are guys that just enjoy building models. Just because they choose to build train models doesn’t mean they ‘have’ to have a layout.
The higher you set the bar when building a layout the smaller it becomes, Bill Darnaby being an exception. Large layouts usually are built with a total different mindset where operations are foremost. At age 69 my new layout will be built realizing time is limited.
I haven’t been able to do any modeling since spring, but keep accumulating freight car kits and material for scratch building structures. Pretty soon I’m going to have to scratch that itch  ;  ))
Clark Propst
Mason City Iowa
 
I think regardless whatever we get out of this presentation what we should
take away is that we should all return to modeling again. Challenge
ourselves to take one of the examples here and apply them to out modeling. We
should set a minimum set of standards for ourselves and as we get better move
those standards ahead even if we start with something as simple as an
ACCURAIL freight car. Hiding behind, "I have a layout to build and that takes all
my time..." does really doesn't make sense when I see Clark do both. Turn
off the computer and put your skills to the challenge.


Greg Martin

 
 
 
-----Original Message-----
From: cepropst@q.com [STMFC]
To: STMFC
Sent: Thu, Oct 29, 2015 8:57 am
Subject: [STMFC] Re: "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation link

 
I saw Bill’s clinic at Naperville. Afterwards a friend said. “Bet he doesn’t have a layout.” I think things need to be taken in context. I understand there are guys that just enjoy building models. Just because they choose to build train models doesn’t mean they ‘have’ to have a layout.
The higher you set the bar when building a layout the smaller it becomes, Bill Darnaby being an exception. Large layouts usually are built with a total different mindset where operations are foremost. At age 69 my new layout will be built realizing time is limited.
I haven’t been able to do any modeling since spring, but keep accumulating freight car kits and material for scratch building structures. Pretty soon I’m going to have to scratch that itch  ;  ))
Clark Propst
Mason City Iowa
 
I think regardless whatever we get out of this presentation what we should
take away is that we should all return to modeling again. Challenge
ourselves to take one of the examples here and apply them to out modeling. We
should set a minimum set of standards for ourselves and as we get better move
those standards ahead even if we start with something as simple as an
ACCURAIL freight car. Hiding behind, "I have a layout to build and that takes all
my time..." does really doesn't make sense when I see Clark do both. Turn
off the computer and put your skills to the challenge.


Greg Martin


Bill Welch
 

It is true I do not have a layout but I am developing some ideas of what I want to do with what I am calling a large Diorama that will have a couple of scenes requiring switching. One scene will be Fresh Produce oriented (big surprise) and the other something typical of a medium size town with a mill or small plant of some kind. I am going to hire Lance Mindheim to design the Track Layout. At age 69, soon to be 70 there is only so much I can do. I will probably apply some of my Detail Addiction to the the track, not all of it but probably in the scenes and what can be easily seen.

Meanwhile I have some structures under construction.

To me it is about picking up our tools and using them to challenge ourselves. My current challenge is developing confidence with weathering.

Stay tuned for information on my Clinic Theme for 2016. Here is a hint: It involves only basic one tool. That should simplify things. (Yeah right, LOL)

Looking forward to 2016 Prototype Rails on The Beach.

Bill Welch


Armand Premo
 


Guyz,Just couldn't resist getting in,perhaps even over my head.I know of individuals  that have really gone to the extreme.Their layout and roster is for a specific railroad on a specific day....now,that is extreme.I have been fortunate enough to have a collection of wheel reports for the railroads I model and use these lists as sort of a shopping list.Extreme by some standards,of course.I tend to invite modelers to my rare op sessions who tend to know less about the road that I model than I do.Thus I can get away with more inaccuratisms.In summary we sometime go overboard striving to recapture an era long gone.My 2 and1/2 cents worth.Armand Premo

----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2015 10:16 AM
Subject: Re: [STMFC] Re: "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation link

 

Right on that Greg & Clark.   One thing you could consider is that many model builders that don't have a home layout instead belong to a club.  That was my case while I lived in an apartment for several years.
 
The main thing though is put down that gadget and do somthing!
 
Tom Casey
 
I saw Bill’s clinic at Naperville. Afterwards a friend said. “Bet he doesn’t have a layout.” I think things need to be taken in context. I understand there are guys that just enjoy building models. Just because they choose to build train models doesn’t mean they ‘have’ to have a layout.
The higher you set the bar when building a layout the smaller it becomes, Bill Darnaby being an exception. Large layouts usually are built with a total different mindset where operations are foremost. At age 69 my new layout will be built realizing time is limited.
I haven’t been able to do any modeling since spring, but keep accumulating freight car kits and material for scratch building structures. Pretty soon I’m going to have to scratch that itch  ;  ))
Clark Propst
Mason City Iowa
 
I think regardless whatever we get out of this presentation what we should
take away is that we should all return to modeling again. Challenge
ourselves to take one of the examples here and apply them to out modeling. We
should set a minimum set of standards for ourselves and as we get better move
those standards ahead even if we start with something as simple as an
ACCURAIL freight car. Hiding behind, "I have a layout to build and that takes all
my time..." does really doesn't make sense when I see Clark do both. Turn
off the computer and put your skills to the challenge.


Greg Martin

 
 
 
-----Original Message-----
From: cepropst@q.com [STMFC]
To: STMFC
Sent: Thu, Oct 29, 2015 8:57 am
Subject: [STMFC] Re: "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation link

 
I saw Bill’s clinic at Naperville. Afterwards a friend said. “Bet he doesn’t have a layout.” I think things need to be taken in context. I understand there are guys that just enjoy building models. Just because they choose to build train models doesn’t mean they ‘have’ to have a layout.
The higher you set the bar when building a layout the smaller it becomes, Bill Darnaby being an exception. Large layouts usually are built with a total different mindset where operations are foremost. At age 69 my new layout will be built realizing time is limited.
I haven’t been able to do any modeling since spring, but keep accumulating freight car kits and material for scratch building structures. Pretty soon I’m going to have to scratch that itch  ;  ))
Clark Propst
Mason City Iowa
 
I think regardless whatever we get out of this presentation what we should
take away is that we should all return to modeling again. Challenge
ourselves to take one of the examples here and apply them to out modeling. We
should set a minimum set of standards for ourselves and as we get better move
those standards ahead even if we start with something as simple as an
ACCURAIL freight car. Hiding behind, "I have a layout to build and that takes all
my time..." does really doesn't make sense when I see Clark do both. Turn
off the computer and put your skills to the challenge.


Greg Martin

No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 2014.0.4842 / Virus Database: 4447/10909 - Release Date: 10/29/15


Ken Adams
 

There was a lot to think about in this presentation. However the comment that "I'll bet he doesn't have a model railroad" and then that he must belong to a club then, did strike a bit of a nerve. 

I have an almost completed Dry Creek Models F-35A 3D printed kit that will see the rails sometime next week. Taking it slowly. Most of the time is in painting and decaling, 

Some of us that are primarily equipment modelers choose to be really loners not belonging to any formal club with club internal personality issues and club administrative overhead.  I do have what is called in the UK a "shunting plank" where completed models and new engines in the collection are tested and photographed.  It is also the repository for structures that I model when that interest. 

My shunting plank is somewhat UK in nature representing Padstow in Cornwall in the summer of 1947. 6 months before nationalization. But my current freight car model building interest is currently Southern Pacific oriented focusing on equipment that would have run on the SP San Ramon branch in 1951-54. The plank being 4 mm scale for scenery but 16.5 mm gauge track that allows US "Lend Lease" equipment ("Black Widow" diesels and early 1950's freight) to run with only Rule 1 applying.

The shunting plank has been some what neglected for upgrades for the last 4 years. But still serves it's purpose in giving me a small place to run equipment and even follow an operations plan that mimics the daily schedule (pronounced shed_yule not sked_yule) of the Southern Railway on a weekday in August of 1947. SP operations are limited to building and rebuilding local freights serving the suburban real estate construction boom that started in the 1950's in the San Ramon valley. 

Ken Adams


gtws00
 

After seeing Bill's presentation I decided to see how I could use his modeling techniques and my own on a Milwaukee Road Ribside 40 foot boxcar. I have added a couple of photos to the photo section to an album called Milwaukee Road Ribside. It has a scratch built Royal F Type slack adjuster with Sergents scale Couplers and more. The more research I do, the more I find I need to add or modify on the Ribside Kit.


George Toman


gary laakso
 

Speedwitch just released its new Railroad Profile 2 on these cars post war.  I just ordered my copy, so no review available now.
 
gary “scrapping rivets” laakso
south of Mike Brock
 

Sent: Sunday, November 01, 2015 8:26 AM
Subject: Re: [STMFC] "Xxtreme Modeling" presentation link
 
 

After seeing Bill's presentation I decided to see how I could use his modeling techniques and my own on a Milwaukee Road Ribside 40 foot boxcar. I have added a couple of photos to the photo section to an album called Milwaukee Road Ribside. It has a scratch built Royal F Type slack adjuster with Sergents scale Couplers and more. The more research I do, the more I find I need to add or modify on the Ribside Kit.


George Toman


Greg Martin
 

George Toman writes:

ter seeing Bill's presentation I decided to see how I could use his modeling techniques and my own on a Milwaukee Road Ribside 40 foot boxcar. I have added a couple of photos to the photo section to an album called Milwaukee Road Ribside. It has a scratch built Royal F Type slack adjuster with Sergents scale Couplers and more. The more research I do, the more I find I need to add or modify on the Ribside Kit.


George Toman
 
George,

Isn't this the case with every project that you become passionate about? It is hard to draw the line.
 
I don't want to put words into Bill's mouth but I believe that this presentation really was meant to inspire not to chase anyone off. I don't think he expects anyone to do everything he does, I just think believes this might grab someone like yourself and hope that you engage and if you need help I am sure he would do his best to help.

We think a lot alike, it's time to use those craftsmen's skills that brought you here in the first place...  3^)   
 
Greg Martin
 
Eventually all things merge into one and a river runs through it.
Norman Maclean