NYC 1916-design steel automobile box car


Eric Hansmann
 

I recently completed the Westerfield Models HO scale resin kit for this classic prototype. As with many of our models, there’s a story within a story. It’s the latest feature on my DesignBuildOp blog. 


Eric Hansmann
Murfreesboro, TN


Jim Betz
 

Eric,

  Nice job!  I'm surprised how 'dense' the information is on this '24 car.  I've
always associated such verbose lettering with later cars - and yet here we
have an early car (I model the late 40's) that has as much if not more
info on it than the cars I'm used to seeing.  I am NOT saying the lettering
is wrong - I'm commenting on my own lack of experience with cars from 
the mid-20's.
                                                                                    - Jim in the PNW


Eric Hansmann
 

Thanks, Jim. Part of the lettering density stems from fewer abbreviations. The letters are also a bit larger in this era.
 
IIRC, you are also a Northern Pacific fan. They didn't include as much lettering detail on their rolling stock. I don't think they followed MCB/ARA/AAR lettering guidelines until the late 1930s. Here's an NP box car in typical 1920s lettering. Outside of their classic arched banner, the car lettering is minimal.
 
 
Here's a Pere Marquette automobile box car in 1926 as-built lettering. Note the lettering on the right end of the car side has all the dimensional detail plus the hardware inventory. I think it's also a slightly smaller size than what is on the NYC car. Also note the NYC put the hardware inventory on the car end rather than the car side,
 
 
This C&NW box car has a similar lettering presentation as the PM car.
 
 
Same with this L&N gondola.
 
 
But this 1926-built B&O M-26b box car has minimal lettering.
 
 
These are just a few of the lettering nuances to follow for mid-1920s modeling. It is a challenge, but quite rewarding when it all comes together.
 
 
Eric Hansmann
Murfreesboro, TN
 
 
 
 

On 11/09/2022 10:21 PM CST Jim Betz <jimbetz@...> wrote:
 
 
Eric,

  Nice job!  I'm surprised how 'dense' the information is on this '24 car.  I've
always associated such verbose lettering with later cars - and yet here we
have an early car (I model the late 40's) that has as much if not more
info on it than the cars I'm used to seeing.  I am NOT saying the lettering
is wrong - I'm commenting on my own lack of experience with cars from 
the mid-20's.
                                                                                    - Jim in the PNW